All formulas
Head to head
HiPP Dutch Organic Stage 1 vs Member's Mark Advantage Premium
In independent testing, Member's Mark Advantage Premium showed lower heavy-metal levels overall (purity 75 vs 74). The full lab numbers, metal by metal:
| Purity score | 74B | 75B |
| Lead ppb | 2.1 | 1.4 |
| Cadmium ppb | 3.4 | 2.9 |
| Aluminum ppb | 160 | 251 |
| Price | $1.31/oz | $0.46/oz |
| Est. cost at 28 oz/day | $5.70/day | $1.99/day |
| Origin | Europe | US |
| Base | Cow's milk | Cow's milk |
| Buy | Buy |
HiPPDutch Organic Stage 1
Member's MarkAdvantage Premium
Lab data: Consumer Reports independent testing, March 2025. Purity scores are relative to the tested cohort — methodology. Not medical advice; consult your pediatrician.